Prophetic Decline—Latest Examples: Presidents Kimball and
Benson
This will be an overview of the subject of prophetic decline
due to health, old age, or both. Before President Monson became Church
President, the previous examples of that were President Spencer W. Kimball and
his successor in the Presidency, Ezra Taft Benson.
First, let’s talk about President Kimball. In 1981, he recognized
his declining health and that of his counselors (Tanner and Romney). As a
result, he called President Hinckley as a counselor. By 1982, took less active
role except for decisions requiring his approval. Starting in 1981, he scaled
back his conference speaking and appearances. He wrote two talks for April
1982; one was read by his personal secretary D. Arthur Haycock (during the
Saturday Morning Session), and a brief, one paragraph talk which he stood to
give, his last public appearance. For April 1985, a video was shown during the
Priesthood Session featuring extracts of previous Priesthood Session addresses
President Kimball had given. He died on November 5, 1985, four years after his
decline began and 3.5 years after stepping back from an active role in Church
leadership.
As noted above, President Tanner was declining in health
as well. His General Conference speaking was limited to a maximum of two
addresses in the April 1980 General Conference (one of which was leading out in
the Sustaining of Church Officers), and to one address per conference during
the final five General Conferences during which he lived. In October 1980, he
spoke briefly after President Kimball’s address opening the Conference (the
address was just over 2.5 minutes). In April 1981, President Tanner was the
second speaker during the Sunday Morning Session (giving a talk that was just
over 6 minutes). The following October, President Tanner closed the conference
with an address that (again, in a talk that was just over 6 minutes). In April
1982, President Tanner preceded President Kimball’s final address with a talk
just short of 5 minutes. And six months later, just short of two months before
his death, President Tanner gave his last General Conference talk, closing out
that conference with another talk under 5 minutes.
President Romney held out slightly better than Presidents
Kimball or Tanner. Though not in great health, he was able to push through to
fill a semi-active role in First Presidency, giving multiple addresses in
General Conference until about the time that President Tanner passed away, and
wasn’t able to participate too much after his call as First Counselor to
President Kimball. The last address President Romney wrote for delivery in
General Conference was read in the April 1983 General Conference was read at
his request by his son George J. during the Saturday Morning Session. Though
rarely seen in public by the time of President Kimball’s passing in 1985,
President Romney, being junior to President Ezra Taft Benson, was, by virtue of
apostolic seniority, named the President of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles. Because
his health was not good, Elder Howard W. Hunter served as the Acting President
to provide active leadership in the quorum for President Romney’s tenure, which
spanned just over 2.5 years.
With the day-to-day responsibility of First Presidency
matters falling to President Hinckley as the only active member of that body,
he turned to President Benson as the President of the Quorum of the Twelve
Apostles to help him with things, as per Church policy and procedure. President
Benson was very loyal to President Hinckley during this time, which was not a
surprise, as President Hinckley was his junior in the apostleship but his
senior in terms of his sole active role in the Quorum of the First Presidency. Starting
in April 1983, President Benson assisted President Hinckley with his General
Conference responsibilities, including leading out in the Sustaining of Church
Officers as requested, and giving two talks per conference, which took place as
follows:
April 1983: As noted above, led out in the Sustaining of
Church Officers. Preceded President Hinckley’s closing address during the
Priesthood Session, and was the first speaker during the Sunday Morning Session
October 1983: Gave the second actual address during the
Saturday Morning Session (following President Hinckley’s talk, which itself had
followed President Hinckley’s shortened version of the Sustaining of Church
Officers) and preceded again President Hinckley’s concluding remarks during the
Priesthood Session.
April 1984: Was the second to speak during the Saturday
Morning Session (following President Hinckley’s combined Sustaining of Church Officers
and first address) and again preceded President Hinckley’s concluding remarks
during the Priesthood Session.
October 1984: The same as April 1984.
April 1985: Once again, was the second to speak during
the Saturday Morning Session (following President Hinckley’s combined opening
address, Sustaining of Church Officers, and review of a then new policy of
having area presidencies serve on site within the US and internationally).
Spoke this time at the beginning of the Priesthood Session.
October 1985: Again spoke directly after President
Hinckley’s opening remarks (although the Sustaining of Church Officers was
delayed during this conference until the top of the Sunday Afternoon Session),
and again was the first speaker during the Priesthood Session.
President Benson’s declining years:
President Benson was fully active and functional for the
first few years of his presidency, but starting in 1989, scaled back his public
appearances and General Conference addresses for the last five years of his
presidency. Thankfully, both of his counselors, Presidents Hinckley and Monson,
were fully able to function during this time (though each had minor health
issues that were dealt with during this time, including minor hospitalizations
and procedures), and they alternated both an increase in addresses and responsibilities
during this time. As a result of President Benson’s condition, the following
was done in terms of General Conferences:
April 1989: President Benson asked President Hinckley to
read his still-remembered address about pride being a universal sin and a
horrible vice at the top of the Saturday Morning Session, and President Monson
to read his address directed to the children of the Church at the close of the
Sunday Afternoon Session. Both counselors spoke during the Priesthood and
Sunday Morning Sessions.
October 1989: President Benson asked President Monson to
read his address directed to the elderly members of the Church. Both counselors
spoke during the Priesthood and Sunday Morning Sessions. At President Benson’s
request, President Hinckley closed the Sunday Afternoon Session not by reading
an address for him, but by using his own words to assure Church members that
the Lord did, was, and would continue to direct His work even in the wake of a
prophet’s decline.
April 1990: Presidents Hinckley and Monson both spoke during
the Priesthood and Sunday Morning Sessions. At President Benson’s request and
with his consent, President Monson opened the conference and President Hinckley
closed it with addresses that quoted many of President Benson’s prior teachings.
October 1990: Same as above, but President Hinckley
opened the conference and President Monson closed it, again with addresses
quoting previous teachings by President Benson.
April 1991: No different from April 1990.
October 1991: No different from October 1990.
April 1992: Same as the previous two Aprils.
October 1992: Same as the previous two Octobers.
April 1993: Similar to the past three Aprils, but the
counselors shared updates about President Benson’s health, conveyed his love
and concern for the Church and its members, and made it more clear that the
words of President Benson they were sharing were as requested and directed by
him.
October 1993: This conference was somewhat different, and
more like they have been for us since 2015. The conference began with the Sustaining
of Church Officers by President Hinckley, saw both counselors speak during the
Priesthood and Sunday Morning Sessions, and neither counselor giving an actual
address at either the opening or concluding sessions of conference.
April 1994: The final conference during which President
Benson was Church President. The conference featured the Sustaining of Church
Officers in its traditional slot at the top of the Saturday Afternoon Session, with
both counselors again speaking during the Priesthood and Sunday Morning
Session. At President Benson’s request, President Monson closed the conference
with a benedictory address using his (President Monson’s) own words. As both
counselors were able to speak when President Benson couldn’t during these
years, the only different thing is that more General Authorities spoke during
this conference to compensate for the absence of a formal message directed by
or using President Benson’s previous counsel.
President Monson:
At this point, President Monson is older than both
Presidents Kimball and Benson were when their active role in day-to-day Church
operations ended. And President Monson will have lived longer than President
Kimball if he is still alive in March 2018. And if, by 2022, President Monson
is still living (which may be possible, as both Presidents Kimball and Benson
lived several years without being actively involved in day-to-day Church
business), he will have lived longer than President Benson. And President Monson
also had several more years of active service as Church President than either
of the other two prior to when he started scaling back his role. Here is a
timeline of significant notes on President Monson’s presidency:
2008-2010: Functioned fully as Church President,
including presiding at every temple dedication or rededication, conducting 3 of
the 5 general sessions of conference, and speaking 4-5 times during General
Conference (4 talks in the general sessions, and once every three conferences
at the General RS/YW Meeting); last conducted a General Conference session in
April 2010.
October 2010-present: Delegated responsibility of
conducting General Conference sessions to his counselors.
2011-2014: Alternated with his counselors in presiding at
temple dedications and rededications (including having Boyd K. Packer,
President of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, preside at the dedication of
the temple for his native Brigham City Utah).
2013: A change is made to include other General
Authorities in the annual Christmas Devotional; President Monson’s last address
in such a devotional.
2014-present: Has delegated temple dedications and
rededications entirely to his counselors. (Though three of the six dedications
done during 2016 were presided over by three of the six senior apostles);
continued to give 4 or 5 General Conference talks every six months; last spoke
in the General Relief Society meeting in October 2013; has had his counselors
alternate speaking duties since then for the RS/YW meeting, and, since 2014, in
the General Women’s Meeting, which was designated as an official General
Conference session in October that same year.
2015-2017: President Monson only speaks twice in each
General Conference. He asks his counselors to take turns speaking in the General
Women’s Session and being the first speaker in the Saturday Morning Session or
the last one during the Sunday Morning Session.
2015: For each of the General Conferences held, the two
addresses he gave took a total around half an hour.
2016-2017: For each of the three General Conferences held
during this time, the two addresses he gave in together totaled just under 10
minutes.
2016: At the invitation of the First Presidency, Elder M.
Russell Ballard serves as Grand Marshall of the annual Days of ’47 KSL Parade
(for Utah’s pioneer day), marking the first year in a long time that a First
Presidency member did not do so.
April 2017: President Monson only attends three of the
six General Conference sessions. An article on the website of the LDS Church News
notes that President Eyring presided at the other three sessions, while the
conference edition of the Ensign, for
the first time in many years, does not list that information. This General
Conference marks the first time President Monson speaks at the beginning of the
Priesthood Session rather than the end of it.
Tuesday May 23, 2017: The Church announced President
Monson would no longer actively participate in meetings, decisions, or
deliberations of the leading brethren, leaving the day-to-day operations of the
Church to the other 14 apostles. He will be consulted on any major decisions
requiring his approval, but will no longer take an active role. This was
verified by the recent report that President Monson did not participate at all
in the recent Seminar for New Mission Presidents.
Friday June 30, 2017: President Monson’s tenure length
makes him the 8th longest serving Church President.
Monday August 21, 2017: President Monson’s 90th
birthday (no word yet on whether or not there will be a public celebration of
this milestone)
Saturday September 23 & 30 & October 1: 187th
Semiannual General Conference
Speaking of the upcoming General Conference (and this
also applies to any other that may occur during whatever remains of President
Monson’s life), it is unknown at present how the above-mentioned announcement
may impact President Monson’s ability to speak for a few minutes in the
Priesthood and Sunday Morning Sessions. I have inquired with the Church about
that very question. If he is not able to, past precedent indicates a few
possibilities for what might happen:
1.
Other speakers in the session will take up those
few minutes, including an additional speaker or two if needed.
2.
A counselor in the First Presidency, a member of
President Monson’s family, or his personal secretary could read an address from
him containing either new counsel or quotations from previous addresses he has
given, including announcing any new temples, which would be done with President
Monson’s permission.
3.
President Nelson, as President of the Quorum of
the Twelve Apostles, could be asked to give a second address at some point,
perhaps during the Priesthood Session.
In considering what might happen in October, I would also
like to mention one other thing. Elder Hales also did not speak during the
Mission President’s Seminar. He has missed previous General Conferences, so it
is possible he might not speak this October either. Until more is known, my
predictions for next General Conference have President Monson and Elder Hales
speaking back-to-back at the top of the Sunday Morning Session. If neither can
speak at all this conference, obviously that will change things, and anywhere
from 1-3 other speakers could take that time.
For now, that is what my study on the subject of past
precedent in this situation has involved. While there are general guidelines
and past precedents to ensure the work of the Church can continue unhindered
and without interruption during the declining years of a Church president, one
thing is sure: any call for President Monson to “retire” or be granted some
kind of emeritus status is not the Lord’s way, and the same holds true for all
other apostles and prophets. Anyone perpetuating those ideas is not under the
direction or influence of the spirit of the Lord. There is, as noted many times
previously, a reason why Church doctrine and practice has been, is, and always
will be for all apostles and Church Presidents to serve until death. The only
other way out of the apostleship is being disfellowshipped or excommunicated,
and that has not happened in this Church since 1943. Though President Monson,
Elder Hales, and perhaps one or two others may be struggling with issues of
illness and old age, to a man, each of our current 15 apostles are righteous
men that have lived lives in harmony with God’s will and have absolutely been
prepared and foreordained prior to this life for the apostleship.
Some of our current apostles will live to succeed
President Monson. Others will pass away. And the Lord has, does, and will
continue to guide how and when such apostolic transitions occur. It is our
solemn duty to sustain these brethren. Our opportunity to sustain them was, is,
and always will be a time to silently voice our support for them. Unless anyone
knows of any grievous transgressions on the part of any of these 15 men, it is
a sacred obligation to sustain them. To adapt statements previously made by
Church presidents Brigham Young and Gordon B. Hinckley, and doctrines taught by
then-Elder Nelson in October 2014, and Elder Bednar one year later, anyone who
asserts or implies that these men are guilty of great or malignant sins, or who
assert that they are unrighteous, “out of touch”, “too old for the job” or
“should be released from active service, or who organizes efforts meant to
vocally express opposition to sustaining these men, while failing to make the
effort as invited to resolve such concerns through proper channels, are not
being moved upon by the spirit of God, and are on the high road to apostasy.
And if they do not repent, they will eventually apostatize as surely as God
lives.
In my opinion, (as I continue to paraphrase statements
made in the above-mentioned addresses), the beauty of having men of maturity at
the head is that they will not be blown about by every wind of doctrine. And
the fact is, were it not for being asked to serve until their dying breaths, we
would have missed out on so many sermons from good men seasoned by years of
experience. Those are not my words, but as surely as I know God lives, I know
they are true. The Lord has, is now, and will continue to control how the
leadership of His Church changes hands, and, for my part, I am content to leave
it in His hands. Just as the origins of this Church are divine, so is the
process by which the leadership thereof changes at His will. Of these things I
gratefully testify in the name of Jesus Christ, Amen.